.jpg)
As writers, we know editing transforms our raw first drafts into polished works. But understanding editing’s three distinct stages is vital for achieving professional quality. What many new writers might not realize, is that editing is anything but a one-size-fits-all process. Not even close. There are three levels of editing and each one has its own unique focus and goals. This blog is meant to demystify these stages and help guide you toward a manuscript that stands out.
In the publishing industry, editing is crucial for a manuscript’s success. (Boost Your Book's Success: The Importance of Editing) Whether you’re self-editing, or hiring a professional team, grasping these stages will ultimately elevate the quality of your work to meet industry standards and can significantly enhance your manuscript’s success in a competitive market.
The first stop on your journey is developmental editing. Sometimes referred to as substantive editing a developmental edit is the most comprehensive, in-depth level of editing your manuscript will go through. Developmental editing is typically done early on, often before your manuscript is complete. Even if your manuscript isn’t finished, an editor can step in to assess outlines, initial chapters, or ongoing work, offering guidance to strengthen your story’s foundation, refine ideas, and ensure yu're retaining consistency throughout your narrative.
The goal in this phase is to identify your manuscript’s strengths and weaknesses and to make recommendations for improvement. Your manuscript will be reviewed for structure, content, and overall organization. In addition, it'll be appraised for tone, how well your characters are developed, plot, and if it fits your intended audience. Your developmental editor will make recommendations for revisions like reorganizing your story, or adding/deleting sections or scenes if need be.
Line, or stylistic editing, is the next level of your editing process. Line editing comes into play once developmental revisions are complete. This step focuses on refining your manuscript at a granular level to enhance its style and clarity. This involves another review of your manuscript. The editor’s goal here is to refine your manuscript’s language, making it more engaging, clear, and concise. Here, sentence structure, syntax, and grammar will be evaluated to identify areas where language is unclear, ambiguous, or overly complex. Suggestions might be made for revisions like rephrasing sentences, adding or deleting words, or improving transitions between sentences. Line edits help you refine your manuscript’s language, making it more effective and engaging to readers.
Copy editing and proofreading represent the final, fine-tooth-comb stages of the editing process, meticulously guaranteeing adherene to linguistic and formatting standards. These final phases will involve a meticulously detailed review, this time focusing on the mechanics such as grammar, punctuation, and spelling. Here, any errors like typos, or formatting inconsistencies will be rectified. The primary goal in this final editing stage is to ensure that your final product is error-free and polished, ready for publication or distribution.
Self-editing a manuscript is entirely feasible and can be effective when approached systematically. To maximize your self-editing process, I suggest spacing out each editing phase with a period of rest. After finishing one stage, put your work aside for a week or two. This break allows for mental distancing, enabling you to approach the next phase with refreshed eyes and heightened objectivity. Each editing session should begin with a clear mind to enhance your ability to spot and correct issues accurately. It’s always helpful to have other eyes on your work as well.
When working with a professional editing team, the process is often divided among specialists, and each stage might involve its own contract detailing services, timelines, fees, rights, confidentiality, and other terms. However, the specifics can vary based on the editing service provider, and some may offer bundled services under one contract. Carefully review and understand these agreements to avoid misunderstandings. Ask questions if you don’t understand something and seeking legal advice if needed is wise.
From draft to bestseller, mastering the trifecta of editing - developmental, line, and copy/proofreading is pivotal in transforming your work. Each stage targets specific aspects of your writing, ensuring your manuscript not only shines but resonates with your intended audience. By grasping these editing layers, you can enhance your writing, turning your ideas into compelling stories that captivate readers. Embrace these steps to refine your manuscript into a polished, impactful piece ready for the world to see.
~Dani
Resources for Aspiring Editors:
The Copyeditor's Handbook by Amy Einsohn: A comprehensive guide to copyediting principles and practices.
The Chicago Manual of Style: The go-to style guide for many editors and publishers.
Merriam-Webster's Collegiate Dictionary and Thesaurus: Essential references for editors.
On Writing Well by William Zinsser: A classic guide to writing non-fiction clearly and effectively.
Courses and Workshops:
Udemy and Coursera: Online platforms with a wide range of editing courses available.
University Extension Programs: Many universities offer continuing education courses in editing and publishing.
Professional Organizations:
Editorial Freelancers Association (EFA): A professional organization for freelance editors, offering resources, networking opportunities, and job listings.
American Copy Editors Society (ACES): A professional organization for copy editors, providing training, certification, and networking opportunities.
Chartered Institute of Editing and Proofreading (CIEP): A UK-based organization offering training, accreditation, and resources for editors and proofreaders.
Tips for Aspiring Editors:
Read extensively: Pay attention to language usage, style, and editing choices in various publications.
Practice your editing skills: Offer to edit for friends, family, or community organizations to gain experience.
Build your network: Attend industry events, connect with editors online, and seek mentorship opportunities.
Stay up-to-date on industry trends: Follow publishing news and participate in professional development activities. By actively engaging with these resources, you can stay well-informed about the ever-evolving landscape of the writing and publishing world:
1. Subscribe to trade magazines and online newsletters such as “Publishers Weekly”, “The Bookseller”, “PW Daily”, or “Book Riot.” They offer insights into market trends, best practices, and emerging genres.
2. Writing Conferences and Workshops: These gatherings often feature panels, workshops, and networking opportunities that keep you informed.
3. Online Communities and Forums: Engage with writers and industry professionals on platforms like Goodreads, Twitter, or LinkedIn groups.
4. Author Associations: Join professional organizations like the Society of Authors, Romance Writers of America, Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America, or equivalent groups in your genre. They often provide newsletters, webinars, and resources on the latest trends.
5. Podcasts: Listen to podcasts that cover industry news, author interviews, and marketing strategies.
6. Social Media Hashtags: Monitor hashtags on social media platforms for live updates and discussions.
7. E-Newsletters: Sign up for newsletters from literary agents, publishers, and established authors who often share market insights.
8. Webinars and Online Courses: Participate in free or paid webinars offered by platforms like Skillshare, Udemy, or Coursera that cover current topics in writing and publishing.
9. Market Reports: Access annual reports from Nielsen BookScan, Bowker, or industry research firms for statistical insights into sales trends and consumer behavior.
Comments